Does Dublin get it on muniwifi?

This week, we learned that municipal Wifi is under discussion here in Dublin. Great. But there’s a sting, of course: it might not be “real” wireless, despite the great claims at ‘bridging the digital divide’. In fact, councillor Naoise Ó Muirí explained it well on RTÉ radio (RealAudio), when he agreed with the presenter’s suggestion that this would be “yellow pack broadband” and volunteered that services like VOIP should be blocked. Hello Net Neutrality Debate.

There’s also this laughable press release from IBEC’s telecoms forum, arguing that municipal wifi would lead to redundancies, network congestion and a flood to end all floods (note: not all of the above may be a true and accurate report of IBEC’s comments). Guess we have an idea of what lies ahead. If these lads had been around at the time of the first public libraries, they would have offered a great defence of the poor booksellers and their starving children. “Libraries won’t cure the digital divide. More bookstores will”. Heaven forbid if anyone should get a good public service system – obviously we are served brilliantly by the current broadband market in Ireland!

Antoin draws attention to the role of schemes like Fon in achieving the City Council’s goals. In Montreal, something similar is well underway in the Ile Sans Fil project.

There’s an informative tender notice on (not!) Note: apparently the key document is unreliable, but I can’t give a direct link, so email me if you run into trouble. And the Municipal WiFi website has oodles of information on how this could be done. Lawrence Lessig has been arguing that properly implemented municipal wifi can help solve the problem of anti-network-neutrality trends: recent Wired column, older conference speech.

The American University Law Review has a brilliant article on the legal issues relating to municipal wifi in the US:

H Travis, “Wi-Fi Everywhere: Universal Broadband Access as Antitrust and Telecommunications Policy”

Should be required reading for anyone involved in the Dublin proposals. This article from December’s Federal Communications Law Review has a good summary of how the debate has played out on that side of the Atlantic. Note that in the US, there have been moves (supported by the big market players) to try and ban local authorities from helping their citizens to get access to information. A worthy cause, as outlined above. The IBEC intervention indicates that this element of the American debate will form part of ours in the very near future.


3 thoughts on “Does Dublin get it on muniwifi?

  1. Ignore Ó’Muirí, he’s a gobshite of a politician to ever admit that anything he’s proposing is “Yellow Pack”.
    The proposal originally arose (in this Council) from Labour’s Anne Carter and Andrew Montague, and on the national political scheme from Labour & the Greens. It should be fast enough to allow people use the internet, without making it so good that it’s useful for bittorrenting. And I don’t think anyone will be crying into their cereal this morning if it runs a good contest against eircon.

  2. Keith, your comments on Ó’Muirí are uncalled for. I approached several Dublin City council politicians that were discussing Muni WiFi for Dublin around the middle of last year. Naoise is the only one who replied and I have been in regular contact with him discussing Muni WiFi.
    He is genuinly interested in this and is not just posturing.
    On the other hand one of the pitfalls that face Muni WiFi is the risk of “interfering” in the free market. If they intend to function as the sole operator on the network they will have to block services such as VOIP to avoid unfair competition. However that situation would be less than desireable.
    The best scenario would be one where the city owns the network, a third party operates it and access is open to third parties…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s